SCHMIGADOON!

Nederlander Theatre

Opened on Broadway: April 20, 2026
Director & Choreographer: Christopher Gattelli
Book, Music, Lyrics: Cinco Paul
Runtime: 2hr. 30min. (1 Intermission)

Opening Night/Current Cast:

• Josh Skinner: Alex Brightman
• Melissa Gimble: Sara Chase
• Reverend Layton: Malik Pancholy
• Mildred Layton: Ana Gasteyer
• Mayor Menlove: Brad Oscar
• Florence Menlove: Ann Harada
• Doc Jorge Lopez: Ivan Hernandez
• Emma Tate: Isabelle McCalla
• Danny Bailey: Max Clayton
• Betsy McDonough: McKenzie Kurtz
• Carson: Ayaan Diop

Understudies:
For Josh: Clyde Alves & Keven Quillon

For Melissa: Kaleigh Cronin & Becca Petersen

For The Reverend: Jess LeProtto & Keven Quillon

For Mildred: Kaleigh Cronin & Lauralyn McClelland

For For The Mayor: Jess LeProtto & Keven Quillon

For Florence: Lauralyn McClelland & Shina Ann Morris

For Doc: Clyde Alves & Nathan Lucrezio

For Emma: Shina Ann Morris & Becca Petersen 

For Danny: Clyde Alves & Zachary Downer

For Betsy: Maria Briggs & Kimberly Immanuel

For Carson: Miles McNicoll

Synopsis:Josh and Melissa are two disillusioned New York doctors whose relationship has hit a stale plateau. During a desperate "relationship retreat" backpacking trip, they cross a mysterious stone bridge and find themselves in Schmigadoon, a vibrant town where life is lived inside the tropes of Golden Age musicals like Oklahoma! and Carousel.
​
To their horror, they learn from the town’s eccentric residents that they are trapped behind the bridge until they experience a transformation of the heart. As they navigate "The Picnic Basket Auction," judgmental town councils, and a series of soaring patter songs, Josh and Melissa must decide if their love is worth fighting for—or if they’d rather take their chances with a local soprano or a rogue carnival barker. It is a hilarious, tuneful love letter (and a sharp parody) to the history of the American musical.

Buy Tickets